Intuition suggests the Universe would be a pretty dreary, pointless exercise without the humanoid. We are like braincells in Her mindCan anyone give a reason why humans exist? Do we have a purpose, a destiny? And if so what is it?
Jump to: Board index
Return to: What is the reason for Human existence?
April 29th, 2012, 7:02 pm
Intuition suggests the Universe would be a pretty dreary, pointless exercise without the humanoid. We are like braincells in Her mindCan anyone give a reason why humans exist? Do we have a purpose, a destiny? And if so what is it?
May 1st, 2012, 12:03 pm
May 1st, 2012, 3:50 pm
I’d question Her benevolence as that’s a sort of vague relative termI believe that human beings were created benevolently by God, primarily for purpose living, enjoying and experiencing life,
Nonsense. She could care less Fan whether you go to churchand secondarilyfor the purpose of worshipping God and giving him praise.
The words go together well in a sentence, the grammar is ok but the meaning eludesI believe that mankind's destiny is to ultimately be reunited with the divine order;
Nonsense. But if there is A God and if She cares at all, let me herewith thank Her for allowing me to live most of my existence between nuclear wardsand that until that time arrives, we will continue to progress (hopefully in a positive direction) as a race.
Nonsense, these are purely relative concepts. Consider the porker for instance, whom we hang up by the back legs then cut his throat so he bleeds to death before eating him, while feeling entirely virtuous. If he were in charge he would consider intelligence a curse and though he might not torture us he would certainly think it ok to keeps us in a muddy pen and feed us garbageI believe that an evidence of this lies in the concepts of good and evil.
See above. The Islamist for instance feels he is doing God’s will when he beats or kills a family member as punishment for having been rapedNo matter what a human being's circumstances are in life, they must make the choice of whether they are going to be good or evil
Yes here I agree; the Entire Megillah seems pretty dreary and senseless without the humanoid. The mechanics of it however are pretty obscureIt would seem that the earth was made for us to inhabit?
If you mean the physical constants, yes. If you mean the potentiality for evolution, yes. If however you mean some arbitrary set of “rules" to please Her then again, nonsenseThe universal laws where in place before we inhabited the earth.
They are an inevitable result of evolution, necessary for survivalChance and probability where in place before we inhabited the earth, did we created feelings and emotions or where they created for us to feel?
May 2nd, 2012, 12:11 pm
Yes Fan but nonetheless thanks for clarificationI know that you will probably regard this as "nonsense,"
May 2nd, 2012, 3:00 pm
Thus Jk the appeal of apodictical existential pantheismand if we can't discover the location, it must be God.
Not to usHuman existence does not exist in order for us to backtrack and answer the question as to why we exist. Sorry this sounds just plain ludicrous.
May 2nd, 2012, 3:37 pm
It is relatively rareWhatever it is, I hope I haven't got it!
Forgive me but if I’m not cogitating under the influence of a kind of grammatical misinterpretation you didn’t specifically identify the question. But you seem to be saying the question of why we exist is less worthy of speculation than why we are here and not somewhere else. Yet the former seems far more interesting and worthy of discussion while the latter is so open to interpretation as to be almost meaninglessI thought there were deeper and more essential questions in philosophy much more worthy of speculation ...like why are we here and not somewhere else!
is the one you consider unworthy I might reword in order to elicit the interest of other participants: The intuitive notion that there’s something more to the Universe than the simple meaningless random bouncing of particles off one another seemingly even more dreary and pointless without the humanoid, suggests that evolution might have been permitted for some purpose or another, especially considering how many of the physical constants seem to have been set up within a fraction of one percent specifically to permit evolution; one of which might be to speculate upon that very purpose; although the mechanism behind it admittedly is still obscureHuman existence does not exist in order for us to backtrack and answer the question as to why we exist.
May 2nd, 2012, 5:49 pm
If you meanWell Yes & No! Don't you think this is the ultimate existential question??
then no, I don’t even know what it means...like why are we here and not somewhere else!
May 3rd, 2012, 12:24 pm
You are quite right Lucy. A quick Googling reveals that people who think about that sort of thing maintain that we’re already overpopulated some 5 to 20 times overWe are an ever evolving virus which will eventually destroy the Earth
May 3rd, 2012, 2:35 pm
Yes I must indeed be a pretty strange personThis is an incredibly strange statement!
If you mean the question whether we have some special significance as at the moment of the Big Bang, its potentiality might nevertheless have been there from Day One or even foreverIf we wouldn't exist the question wouldn't either and nothing would have changed
Certainly not in the conventional sense, where we seem insignificantYou presuppose that it is WE who are giving it or granting it some kind of meaning.
To the contrary, a very conservative estimate—that is only one inhabitable planet per galaxy—places our number at three sextillionYou also presuppose there is no one else out there with our level of consciousness that could make it a meaningful exercise
THAT I presume you mean a kind of significance but if not please feel free to clarifyas if THAT were even required.
In a certain existential wayAnd not least you imply the Universe was created essentially for us
That’s the intuitive feelingthat without us it's a meaningless exercise.
Quite so but the potential for our reinstatement persistsThe Cosmos can annul us out of existence anytime and there wouldn't even so much as a localized Whimper in the aftermath.
Yes. I take this opportunity therefore herewith to thank her for having let me live most of my life between nuclear warsWe're as dispensable as a flea on a dog.
I suppose that depends upon what you include as “our planet."Our own planet couldn't care less if we exist or not.
Not sure what you mean. If “We need Her more than She needs us,” perhaps so but only if you define “need" in terms of our immediate feelings in an apodictical senseWe need it, not the other way around.
May 3rd, 2012, 2:49 pm
Hj is he some sort of Admin moderatorBut Geheime Staatspolizei. Would not allow it
May 3rd, 2012, 2:57 pm
It that includes us, Jk, the yes I suppose it does careWhat I meant was the whole rotundity of said entity.
Uni It’s like the rest of the Megillah. Eventually it will be shown that All exists because the idea of nothingness entails paradoxes and contradictions so in a pantheistic sense the Universe is the way it is because that’s the way She has to be, Things can’t be any other wayWhy does man exist?
If for no other reason it satisfied the above intuitive notionCan anyone give a reason why humans exist?
To just be, I guess, do things, think about and appreciate what we are as Pimp infers aboveDo we have a purpose, a destiny? And if so what is it??
May 3rd, 2012, 7:17 pm
Everything you are XD except possibly your bodyHjarloprillar, Is there such a thing as a soul?
Not required of this defIf no, people say there is; if yes, where's the proof?
We could start I suppose with the bodyWhat does there have to be to make something exist, to be such a thing?
Sure why notIf there is a collective consciousness, then why couldn't there be collective imagination?
May 3rd, 2012, 8:47 pm
Yes Uni, Kin is absolutely right. As it becomes more an more organized the Digital World will further coalesce, submitting humans to an even more obvious state of bondage. We see it happening every day, folks walking around everywhere carrying one of those book-like affairs; people like myself addicted to the Internet Forum to the detriment of other duties. But we won’t realize what’s happening because its technique is to enslave us in exactly this manner- you are saying the internet is an organized entity - a thing with a cognitive self.
May 4th, 2012, 2:05 am
Alas true Sch. Maybe Uni, Kin and I should go start a new threadThese most recent comments re the Internet while interesting, are "off topic".
Uni it already hasvery real possibility that AI {artificial intelligence} will advance beyond human control
The Internet is a part of the reality that faces us and bringing us under its control, one of its major means of interconnection or “thought”. True it will consolidate further, almost all of us happily unaware, blissfully and enthusiastically cooperativethen the internet becomes the medium of infection - but the infection has to be introduced into it.
More general than your perception the Digital World is already far into the project and we are serving its needs admirablyBut if some unknown and highly advanced AI intelligence decides that the reason for human existence is to serve its needs
May 5th, 2012, 2:33 pm
Not at all Windy (forgive pun)If there was a purpose to human existence wouldn't everyone know what the purpose is,
Return to: What is the reason for Human existence?
© 2007-2011 OnlinePhilosophyClub.com, Scott Hughes.
Please suggest ways to make the forums even better!