This is my nomination for the best post in the thread.Greta wrote:Can't you see that this thread is about laughing at human goofiness? Country music is goofy. That's okay, not a hanging offence, but it is something we can joke about. Do you *really* believe Alec - and we are talking about Alec here - is serious when he talks about the need not to "tolerate" country music? I am in full agreement with him, of course. We should clap the bastards in irons until they desist - every damn check-shirted and fringe skirted guitar-wielder and caterwauler3uGH7D4MLj wrote:That makes me wonder, is it class, politics, elitism? -- bigotry?
The only serious criticism made all thread is that country music and its deliberate lack of flair bores a lot of people, although Alec has a particular allergy to line dancing. I expect that in a previous life he was trampled to death by line dancers.
Your bigotry hypothesis looks like an attempt to imbue philosophical meaning to a joke. Plenty of people who find country music to be dull and prosaic will respond positively to a lively hillbilly romp. Yet hillbillies are the epitome of what anti-country music people are supposed to be prejudiced against. Identity politics exists in music as it does in everything humans do, but only to a great extent in very young people, after which time identity tends to be more associated with relationships, work and skills.
-- Updated 24 Oct 2015, 20:49 to add the following --
JKlint, I liked Comanche's raw sparseness but I couldn't sit through it.
Country music, is it OK?
- Alec Smart
- Posts: 671
- Joined: June 28th, 2015, 12:28 pm
Re: Country music, is it OK?
- LuckyR
- Moderator
- Posts: 7987
- Joined: January 18th, 2015, 1:16 am
Re: Country music, is it OK?
IMO, it's OK, I mean it bears "toleration".Alec Smart wrote:This is my nomination for the best post in the thread.Greta wrote: (Nested quote removed.)
Can't you see that this thread is about laughing at human goofiness? Country music is goofy. That's okay, not a hanging offence, but it is something we can joke about. Do you *really* believe Alec - and we are talking about Alec here - is serious when he talks about the need not to "tolerate" country music? I am in full agreement with him, of course. We should clap the bastards in irons until they desist - every damn check-shirted and fringe skirted guitar-wielder and caterwauler
The only serious criticism made all thread is that country music and its deliberate lack of flair bores a lot of people, although Alec has a particular allergy to line dancing. I expect that in a previous life he was trampled to death by line dancers.
Your bigotry hypothesis looks like an attempt to imbue philosophical meaning to a joke. Plenty of people who find country music to be dull and prosaic will respond positively to a lively hillbilly romp. Yet hillbillies are the epitome of what anti-country music people are supposed to be prejudiced against. Identity politics exists in music as it does in everything humans do, but only to a great extent in very young people, after which time identity tends to be more associated with relationships, work and skills.
-- Updated 24 Oct 2015, 20:49 to add the following --
JKlint, I liked Comanche's raw sparseness but I couldn't sit through it.
- Sy Borg
- Site Admin
- Posts: 15148
- Joined: December 16th, 2013, 9:05 pm
Re: Country music, is it OK?
- 3uGH7D4MLj
- Posts: 934
- Joined: January 4th, 2013, 3:39 pm
Re: Country music, is it OK?
I have full respect and admiration for Alec's (and your) unmoving ironic stance. It brings a nice jokey tone to the discussion.Greta wrote:Can't you see that this thread is about laughing at human goofiness? Country music is goofy. That's okay, not a hanging offence, but it is something we can joke about. Do you *really* believe Alec - and we are talking about Alec here - is serious when he talks about the need not to "tolerate" country music? I am in full agreement with him, of course. We should clap the bastards in irons until they desist - every damn check-shirted and fringe skirted guitar-wielder and caterwauler3uGH7D4MLj wrote:That makes me wonder, is it class, politics, elitism? -- bigotry?
The only serious criticism made all thread is that country music and its deliberate lack of flair bores a lot of people, although Alec has a particular allergy to line dancing. I expect that in a previous life he was trampled to death by line dancers.
Your bigotry hypothesis looks like an attempt to imbue philosophical meaning to a joke. Plenty of people who find country music to be dull and prosaic will respond positively to a lively hillbilly romp. Yet hillbillies are the epitome of what anti-country music people are supposed to be prejudiced against. Identity politics exists in music as it does in everything humans do, but only to a great extent in very young people, after which time identity tends to be more associated with relationships, work and skills.
You're saying that there's nothing more than that going on.
I don't agree. I base my take on observations in my region of the world. We live on different continents, so there's that. Bigotry? absolutely worth considering.
- Alec Smart
- Posts: 671
- Joined: June 28th, 2015, 12:28 pm
Re: Country music, is it OK?
There is a serious element to this thread but it is directed more at the American "red neck" devotees rather than the music itself. The apreciation of music is purely a matter of taste and I just happen to think country music is awful.3uGH7D4MLj wrote: I have full respect and admiration for Alec's (and your) unmoving ironic stance. It brings a nice jokey tone to the discussion.
You're saying that there's nothing more than that going on.
I don't agree. I base my take on observations in my region of the world. We live on different continents, so there's that. Bigotry? absolutely worth considering.
- Rederic
- Posts: 589
- Joined: May 30th, 2012, 8:26 am
- Favorite Philosopher: Bertrand Russell
- Location: South coast of England
Re: Country music, is it OK?
Earlier in the thread you were espousing the virtues of blues music against country, now you criticise country music for being too repetitive. Have you ever studied twelve bar blues music. Personally, I love it, but you can't get more repetitive than this. Also, many orchestral music pieces start with a theme & then go on to play variations on this same theme.Greta wrote:I get bored with it too. Aside from hillbilly romps, country music is all about the words and I've never been good at following wordy lyrics; if your attention slips for a moment you miss a crucial passage, then the song meaning can be lost.Belinda wrote:Isn't country music a little too repetitive in form ?
One can have a refrain but when there is no variation between the repetitions I find my attention wandering. Maybe country music varies in quality and I have heard only the more banal sort.
So, to avoid distraction, each country song more or less finishes as it starts with few, if any, surprises. A buildup if you're lucky and a relative lack of flair, flamboyance, daring, excitement and imagination - delivered with exaggerated a lack of affectation to the point of affectation.
In truth, all music is OK. There's a saying that "hunger makes the best sauce". If you're starving then a Big Mac may seem like the most beautiful substance that ever passed your lips. So if I was deprived of music for a long time I would no doubt find Toby Keith's music to be nectar for the ears. Fortunately, there's plenty of other music around .
Think of people hose who have lived through dictatorships where the only music approved of involves tiresome praises to a deity or militaristic ditties about some "glorious" leader (ie. butcher). To the oppressed citizens of such places Tammy Wynette would be a source of excitement and beauty rather than insomnia aid.
-- Updated 22 Oct 2015, 17:09 to add the following --
Typo last para:
"Think of people hose who have lived" ... there is no hose.
You admit that you don't like words in music. Is this your excuse for your particular dislike of country music, or does it apply to blues music, pop, opera or any other type of oral music?
You could just admit that you just don't like it without wrapping it up in your musical snobbery.
It is at its worst when it deludes us into thinking we have all the answers for everybody else.
Archibald Macleish.
- LumiNara
- New Trial Member
- Posts: 1
- Joined: October 26th, 2015, 7:00 pm
Re: Country music, is it OK?
- Sy Borg
- Site Admin
- Posts: 15148
- Joined: December 16th, 2013, 9:05 pm
Re: Country music, is it OK?
Re blues: you can enjoy blues while entirely disregarding the lyrics. Besides, there's usually only a few words in each tune most times.
That's the rub - how to make music that is alive while not distracting from the lyrics. My measure for music of interest (usually) is, if the vocals were sung in another language would be music still be compelling?
Every now and then a lyric will grab me. Pink Floyd's in Dark Side of the Moon, for example - brilliant! But so was the music. And the words were clearly enunciated and delivered at a civilised pace that allowed the listener to still soak up the music.
Why aren't country fans who reject other forms considered to be snobbish? Hmmm ....
-
- Posts: 1719
- Joined: February 23rd, 2012, 3:06 am
Re: Country music, is it OK?
Why not ask people who pay dearly to attend opera performances who understand neither Italian, German, French or Russian. The same goes for listening to folk songs from all over. In fact most people prefer to listen to the original language even if a translation were available the reason for which is simple. The inflections of language are part of the sound and in music it's the 'sound' which takes priority.Greta wrote: My measure for music of interest (usually) is, if the vocals were sung in another language would be music still be compelling?
I have no interest in trying to convince anyone of this but your question is rather weird when considering all the people who enjoy the music and the voices without having to know the language. Sensitivities vary so who cares. There are those who would give up Beethoven for Sid Vicious.
- Sy Borg
- Site Admin
- Posts: 15148
- Joined: December 16th, 2013, 9:05 pm
Re: Country music, is it OK?
Then maybe we should release an album of country greats sung in Welsh and we'll see how the sales go without the music relying on words to carry it.Jklint wrote:... your question is rather weird when considering all the people who enjoy the music and the voices without having to know the language. Sensitivities vary so who cares. There are those who would give up Beethoven for Sid Vicious.
- Rederic
- Posts: 589
- Joined: May 30th, 2012, 8:26 am
- Favorite Philosopher: Bertrand Russell
- Location: South coast of England
Re: Country music, is it OK?
Feel free, but I'd have to listen to it before I bought it.Greta wrote:Then maybe we should release an album of country greats sung in Welsh and we'll see how the sales go without the music relying on words to carry it.Jklint wrote:... your question is rather weird when considering all the people who enjoy the music and the voices without having to know the language. Sensitivities vary so who cares. There are those who would give up Beethoven for Sid Vicious.
It is at its worst when it deludes us into thinking we have all the answers for everybody else.
Archibald Macleish.
- Sy Borg
- Site Admin
- Posts: 15148
- Joined: December 16th, 2013, 9:05 pm
Re: Country music, is it OK?
Why are you country fans so snobbish against these wonderful forms of music? If you don't like them, why not?
Rederic, you can start ...
- Rederic
- Posts: 589
- Joined: May 30th, 2012, 8:26 am
- Favorite Philosopher: Bertrand Russell
- Location: South coast of England
Re: Country music, is it OK?
It is at its worst when it deludes us into thinking we have all the answers for everybody else.
Archibald Macleish.
- Sy Borg
- Site Admin
- Posts: 15148
- Joined: December 16th, 2013, 9:05 pm
Re: Country music, is it OK?
I answered a question honestly and you criticise me for "pseudo explanations", as though you believe you can read my mind. You then fail to answer a clear question put to you - and then paint your failure to understand or analyse your responses to music as a virtue. Are you afraid that such analysis will "spoil the magic"?Rederic wrote:OK. I listen to country, blues, rock, some pop, folk, trad jazz & classical. I love chamber & quartet music by most of the big composers but especially baroque. I don't listen to much dance or electronic music because I'm an old git & prefer my music played by human musicians. Notice I don't wrap it up with pseudo explanations. I just plain don't like it.
So I'll ask again - why don't you like modern jazz, free jazz, experimental music and progressive rock? No more avoidance or getting competitive and pretending to be more honest or virtuous - just try responding without the attitude.
- Rederic
- Posts: 589
- Joined: May 30th, 2012, 8:26 am
- Favorite Philosopher: Bertrand Russell
- Location: South coast of England
Re: Country music, is it OK?
Because I like to listen to music that I enjoy. I don't want to be challenged by music. I don't talk about the supposed political or cultural reasons for disliking a genre of music, that's just nonsense. We're all products of our upbringing & words are important to me. In the UK we're brought up with books, poetry & music separately & together. Perhaps it's different in Australia?Greta wrote:I answered a question honestly and you criticise me for "pseudo explanations", as though you believe you can read my mind. You then fail to answer a clear question put to you - and then paint your failure to understand or analyse your responses to music as a virtue. Are you afraid that such analysis will "spoil the magic"?Rederic wrote:OK. I listen to country, blues, rock, some pop, folk, trad jazz & classical. I love chamber & quartet music by most of the big composers but especially baroque. I don't listen to much dance or electronic music because I'm an old git & prefer my music played by human musicians. Notice I don't wrap it up with pseudo explanations. I just plain don't like it.
So I'll ask again - why don't you like modern jazz, free jazz, experimental music and progressive rock? No more avoidance or getting competitive and pretending to be more honest or virtuous - just try responding without the attitude.
It is at its worst when it deludes us into thinking we have all the answers for everybody else.
Archibald Macleish.
2023/2024 Philosophy Books of the Month
Mark Victor Hansen, Relentless: Wisdom Behind the Incomparable Chicken Soup for the Soul
by Mitzi Perdue
February 2023
Rediscovering the Wisdom of Human Nature: How Civilization Destroys Happiness
by Chet Shupe
March 2023