Why are people so against the Mormons?
- Lark_Truth
- Posts: 212
- Joined: December 24th, 2016, 11:51 am
- Favorite Philosopher: Brandon Sanderson
Why are people so against the Mormons?
Mormon polygamy was stopped in 1889, and even then those who practiced it during that time were not a majority among the membership of the Church, and those plural marriages were not harems. I might also mention that those who had the American Congress force the bill to make polygamy illegal were doing things with lots of women they weren't even married to. Magic underwear is another false rumor, and the detail behind it can be found on either Mormon.org or LDS.org.
Besides the two main false rumors, there are dozens of more that are still false and others that have had their truths twisted to look evil. Wherever there are large bodies of Mormons gathered, there are protesters (I guess you could call them that) having anti-mormon rallies, passing out anti-mormon literature, trying to denounce the Church.
Why are people so against the Mormons? Sure, they're against homosexual marriage, most cases of abortion, and other stuff that you can also find on Mormon.org which the church has taken a very strong stance against, but they don't pay any of their General Authorities, Stake Presidents and Leaders, Missionaries, Bishops, or preachers (they don't have preachers! congregation members give the sermons). The only ones who earn their living by the Church are those who have full time jobs to run it, accountants for instance to keep track of where all of the funds are going. All of the tithing that Mormons pay into their church goes into running the church, paying for their church houses and temples, charity, humanitarian aid, etc.
All of what I have described is just the tip of the iceberg. The Mormons are wonderful people and don't deserve such treatment from their fellow men.
So why are people so against the Mormons?
- LuckyR
- Moderator
- Posts: 7991
- Joined: January 18th, 2015, 1:16 am
Re: Why are people so against the Mormons?
There are as many reasons why various folks dislike, don't trust and/or try to stop the Mormon church. Before I get into that though, for me personally, what separates the Mormon church from a lot of other religions is the tithing. Giving (or taking depending on your perspective) 10% of PRETAX income is in the Madoff zone. In another context it would be considered criminal and getting tax-exempt status on top of that just shows the power of the church over government. Somewhere between sad and scary.Lark_Truth wrote:The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints is one of the religions where non-members and others seem to have a lot of wrong ideas about. Nicknamed "Mormons" because of the book of scripture, the Book of Mormon: Another Testament of Jesus Christ, a complement to the Holy Bible, the Church has undergone a lot of persecution from physical attacks to people spreading false rumors. Physical attacks have not happened so much ever since the early eighteen hundreds during the Church's early years, but many people still seem to think that Mormon men have lots of wives and that they all wear magic underwear.
Mormon polygamy was stopped in 1889, and even then those who practiced it during that time were not a majority among the membership of the Church, and those plural marriages were not harems. I might also mention that those who had the American Congress force the bill to make polygamy illegal were doing things with lots of women they weren't even married to. Magic underwear is another false rumor, and the detail behind it can be found on either Mormon.org or LDS.org.
Besides the two main false rumors, there are dozens of more that are still false and others that have had their truths twisted to look evil. Wherever there are large bodies of Mormons gathered, there are protesters (I guess you could call them that) having anti-mormon rallies, passing out anti-mormon literature, trying to denounce the Church.
Why are people so against the Mormons? Sure, they're against homosexual marriage, most cases of abortion, and other stuff that you can also find on Mormon.org which the church has taken a very strong stance against, but they don't pay any of their General Authorities, Stake Presidents and Leaders, Missionaries, Bishops, or preachers (they don't have preachers! congregation members give the sermons). The only ones who earn their living by the Church are those who have full time jobs to run it, accountants for instance to keep track of where all of the funds are going. All of the tithing that Mormons pay into their church goes into running the church, paying for their church houses and temples, charity, humanitarian aid, etc.
All of what I have described is just the tip of the iceberg. The Mormons are wonderful people and don't deserve such treatment from their fellow men.
So why are people so against the Mormons?
OK, as what bothers typical citizens is NOT the above rather it is a combination of:
1- Competition with standard Christianity, as many consider the "Latter Day" aspect to be blasphemy or a twisting of that faith.
2- Splinter groups of the Mormon church who use polygamy as a cover for pedophilia
3- Forced missions, as some find proselytizing to be off-putting
4- Historically the Mormon church has discriminated against blacks until 1979.
5- Many consider the "magical" nature of the church history to be comical or fake and thus believers to be duped or rubes.
I am certain I am missing many other objections that citizens have against the Mormon church.
- Sy Borg
- Site Admin
- Posts: 15154
- Joined: December 16th, 2013, 9:05 pm
Re: Why are people so against the Mormons?
-
- Posts: 1366
- Joined: August 18th, 2016, 11:29 am
- Favorite Philosopher: Paul Tillich
Re: Why are people so against the Mormons?
They're bigots. What a person believes is between them and their God.Lark_Truth wrote:The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints is one of the religions where non-members and others seem to have a lot of wrong ideas about. Nicknamed "Mormons" because of the book of scripture, the Book of Mormon: Another Testament of Jesus Christ, a complement to the Holy Bible, the Church has undergone a lot of persecution from physical attacks to people spreading false rumors. Physical attacks have not happened so much ever since the early eighteen hundreds during the Church's early years, but many people still seem to think that Mormon men have lots of wives and that they all wear magic underwear.
Mormon polygamy was stopped in 1889, and even then those who practiced it during that time were not a majority among the membership of the Church, and those plural marriages were not harems. I might also mention that those who had the American Congress force the bill to make polygamy illegal were doing things with lots of women they weren't even married to. Magic underwear is another false rumor, and the detail behind it can be found on either Mormon.org or LDS.org.
Besides the two main false rumors, there are dozens of more that are still false and others that have had their truths twisted to look evil. Wherever there are large bodies of Mormons gathered, there are protesters (I guess you could call them that) having anti-mormon rallies, passing out anti-mormon literature, trying to denounce the Church.
Why are people so against the Mormons? Sure, they're against homosexual marriage, most cases of abortion, and other stuff that you can also find on Mormon.org which the church has taken a very strong stance against, but they don't pay any of their General Authorities, Stake Presidents and Leaders, Missionaries, Bishops, or preachers (they don't have preachers! congregation members give the sermons). The only ones who earn their living by the Church are those who have full time jobs to run it, accountants for instance to keep track of where all of the funds are going. All of the tithing that Mormons pay into their church goes into running the church, paying for their church houses and temples, charity, humanitarian aid, etc.
All of what I have described is just the tip of the iceberg. The Mormons are wonderful people and don't deserve such treatment from their fellow men.
So why are people so against the Mormons?
-- Updated January 29th, 2017, 12:22 pm to add the following --
Note: Spiral Out didn't like me simply saying "They're bigots" even though it is demonstrably true and on subject.
- Sy Borg
- Site Admin
- Posts: 15154
- Joined: December 16th, 2013, 9:05 pm
Re: Why are people so against the Mormons?
How does "What a person believes is between them and their God" especially apply to Mormons? It's hardly uncommon for theists to reject those who subscribe to different faiths, hence words like "heretic" and "infidel". So what makes Mormons especially bigoted? I'm obviously not an adherent, but I find unfounded criticisms like those you made about Mormons as jarring as if you made claims about me or other "agnostics".
Maybe there is a real issue, but you have to do better than making accusations. That's fine for Facebook and Twitter but Scott's hoping to raise the bar here just a little, nothing fancy or impressive, just somewhat of a refuge for those who are more interested in comparing ideas than grumpy cut and thrust. The latter is readily available elsewhere.
So, can/will you explain the issues you perceive with Mormonism without prejudice?
-
- Posts: 1366
- Joined: August 18th, 2016, 11:29 am
- Favorite Philosopher: Paul Tillich
Re: Why are people so against the Mormons?
Many people claim to be tolerant and open-minded, but are hateful and intolerant when the rubber meets the road. (Did you hear some of the in the recent anti-Trump demonstrations? Same thing, different venue.)
-- Updated January 29th, 2017, 11:09 pm to add the following --
I was referring to the critics of Mormons, not Mormons.
-- Updated January 29th, 2017, 11:12 pm to add the following --
IMV, I'm owed an apology. Was it prejudice that caused you and Spiral Out to jump to a false conclusion?
- Sy Borg
- Site Admin
- Posts: 15154
- Joined: December 16th, 2013, 9:05 pm
Re: Why are people so against the Mormons?
Is there going to be apology from you for giving unpaid moderators extra work because you so often disregard forum rules? I thought not.
- Lark_Truth
- Posts: 212
- Joined: December 24th, 2016, 11:51 am
- Favorite Philosopher: Brandon Sanderson
Re: Why are people so against the Mormons?
LuckyR, you gave some great reasons as to why there are people against the LDS Church. I might add that some other Christian denominations dislike the church because their missionaries steal their members. Can't say I blame them there. But I must ask in the third reason you gave on your list, are you saying that the LDS Church force their young men and women to go on missions?LuckyR wrote:There are as many reasons why various folks dislike, don't trust and/or try to stop the Mormon church. Before I get into that though, for me personally, what separates the Mormon church from a lot of other religions is the tithing. Giving (or taking depending on your perspective) 10% of PRETAX income is in the Madoff zone. In another context it would be considered criminal and getting tax-exempt status on top of that just shows the power of the church over government. Somewhere between sad and scary.
OK, as what bothers typical citizens is NOT the above rather it is a combination of:
1- Competition with standard Christianity, as many consider the "Latter Day" aspect to be blasphemy or a twisting of that faith.
2- Splinter groups of the Mormon church who use polygamy as a cover for pedophilia
3- Forced missions, as some find proselytizing to be off-putting
4- Historically the Mormon church has discriminated against blacks until 1979.
5- Many consider the "magical" nature of the church history to be comical or fake and thus believers to be duped or rubes.
Yes, for some reason there was racial discrimination in the Church. Why? I don't know. I know of an essay that covers the topic on LDS.org. It doesn't quite give an explanation as to why this happened, but it gives the history as to why the Priesthood was withheld from those of African decent and a lot of theories as to why it may have happened.
And you are right about the splinter groups. The doctrine of plural marriage among the early Mormon Church was not meant as an excuse for harems. There are splinter groups who still try to get around the law about polygamy today, and many of them are called Mormons, but are not to be confused with the LDS Church. Some are called the Revised LDS Church (RLDS) and have a lot of different beliefs (such as polygamy) than the original Mormon Church.
Greta, if you want to know just why over 15 million people (I think, that number was announced years ago) believe in Mormonism, then I advise you check out Mormon.org and see for yourself.
And yes, let's try to delve into these issues without prejudice.
Please post more!
- ExodusMe
- New Trial Member
- Posts: 2
- Joined: January 30th, 2017, 1:16 pm
Re: Why are people so against the Mormons?
Also, I think the internet/information age has become a serious burden to modern religions. There are so many scholars and exegetes that literally every error is uncovered in any type of historical text. Mormonism has been destroyed because of this. Anyone with an internet connection can look up Mormonism origins and see that it was founded by a 19 year old man who went into a cave and 'received' gold plated scripture that magically 'disappeared' that gave him the authority to marry multiple women (many of whom were already married). There are also numerous issues with the Mormon text including its reference to populations and land masses that never existed. The Mormon text also has anachronisms that place horses and types of vegetation on North America in the ancient world that did not come about until Spain brought them over. All of this coupled with the fact that Mormonism claims to usurp Christianity because the apostles didn't lay their hands on their followers appropriately to spread the Holy Spirit.
-
- Posts: 3601
- Joined: February 28th, 2014, 4:50 pm
Re: Why are people so against the Mormons?
In what way does this question differ from the question of why are people so against any X? Is it a question about religion? If so, then how does it differ from the question of why are people so against the Jews? Why are people so against the Catholics? Why are people so against the Muslims? Or is it a matter of group identity? Why are people so against the Blacks? Why are people so against the French? Why are people so against the LGBT? Why are people so against the Republicans? Why are people so against the liberals?So why are people so against the Mormons?
-
- Posts: 1104
- Joined: March 18th, 2011, 4:57 pm
- Favorite Philosopher: Anaximander
Re: Why are people so against the Mormons?
Anyway, I've learned a lot from my wife and her participation in ex-Mormon websites. The religion is so blatantly and obviously an invention of Joseph Smith and his need to rationalize his pedophilia that it makes me sick to even consider the gullibility of its followers. Actually, I was going to say more but I'm making myself angry so I'm gonna quit here.
-
- Posts: 240
- Joined: June 19th, 2014, 5:30 pm
Re: Why are people so against the Mormons?
There may be a variety of reasons why people are against any X. In some cases it may be obvious why Y is against X. For example, X is at war with Y, so Y is against X.Fooloso4 wrote:
In what way does this question differ from the question of why are people so against any X? Is it a question about religion? If so, then how does it differ from the question of why are people so against the Jews? Why are people so against the Catholics? Why are people so against the Muslims? Or is it a matter of group identity? Why are people so against the Blacks? Why are people so against the French? Why are people so against the LGBT? Why are people so against the Republicans? Why are people so against the liberals?Lark_Truth wrote:So why are people so against the Mormons?
In other cases the reasons may be more subtle or otherwise less obvious, begging the question why Y is against a specific X ("what has X done to Y that is so bad for Y to be so against X?").
Perhaps the variety of reasons all boil down to a common reason that applies to any given "Y is against X"?
In each case, there may be a belief that X is somehow harming or threatening to harm Y or that there is a high chance that X will harm Y. This harm could be physical, but may just be psychological or ideological. There may be a real or imaginary sense that X is against Y, so Y is against X.
This sense may not be direct. If Y identifies with or supports Z, and Y believes that X is against Z, then Y may also believe that X is against Y, leading Y to be against X, even if Z is just an idea.
In some cases, Y may feel that X is against Y even if X believes they are for Y. This can happen if X is religious and trying to convert Y. X may believe they are trying to help and improve Y, and Y may agree if X is successful, but if X is trying to change Y then it can be argued that X is actually against Y and only for a modified version of Y.
If X is for Z then X is implicitly against anything that is not Z, compared to Z. Being pro something will naturally attract opposing anti feelings.
If X is strongly for itself (if X has a strong sense of superiority, eg, master race, God's chosen people, only true church), and Y is not X, then X will implicitly be against Y (viewed as inferior relative to X), perhaps without realising this. Even if X is not explicitly against Y, X's sense of superiority may be reflected in X's behaviour towards Y. This may be viewed as an attack on Y's ego, leading Y to be against X.
- Sy Borg
- Site Admin
- Posts: 15154
- Joined: December 16th, 2013, 9:05 pm
Re: Why are people so against the Mormons?
- LuckyR
- Moderator
- Posts: 7991
- Joined: January 18th, 2015, 1:16 am
Re: Why are people so against the Mormons?
I am using forced to mean peer pressured "forced", not gun to your head "forced".Lark_Truth wrote:Hey guys, thanks for the replies.LuckyR, you gave some great reasons as to why there are people against the LDS Church. I might add that some other Christian denominations dislike the church because their missionaries steal their members. Can't say I blame them there. But I must ask in the third reason you gave on your list, are you saying that the LDS Church force their young men and women to go on missions?LuckyR wrote:There are as many reasons why various folks dislike, don't trust and/or try to stop the Mormon church. Before I get into that though, for me personally, what separates the Mormon church from a lot of other religions is the tithing. Giving (or taking depending on your perspective) 10% of PRETAX income is in the Madoff zone. In another context it would be considered criminal and getting tax-exempt status on top of that just shows the power of the church over government. Somewhere between sad and scary.
OK, as what bothers typical citizens is NOT the above rather it is a combination of:
1- Competition with standard Christianity, as many consider the "Latter Day" aspect to be blasphemy or a twisting of that faith.
2- Splinter groups of the Mormon church who use polygamy as a cover for pedophilia
3- Forced missions, as some find proselytizing to be off-putting
4- Historically the Mormon church has discriminated against blacks until 1979.
5- Many consider the "magical" nature of the church history to be comical or fake and thus believers to be duped or rubes.
Yes, for some reason there was racial discrimination in the Church. Why? I don't know. I know of an essay that covers the topic on LDS.org. It doesn't quite give an explanation as to why this happened, but it gives the history as to why the Priesthood was withheld from those of African decent and a lot of theories as to why it may have happened.
And you are right about the splinter groups. The doctrine of plural marriage among the early Mormon Church was not meant as an excuse for harems. There are splinter groups who still try to get around the law about polygamy today, and many of them are called Mormons, but are not to be confused with the LDS Church. Some are called the Revised LDS Church (RLDS) and have a lot of different beliefs (such as polygamy) than the original Mormon Church.
Greta, if you want to know just why over 15 million people (I think, that number was announced years ago) believe in Mormonism, then I advise you check out Mormon.org and see for yourself.
And yes, let's try to delve into these issues without prejudice.
Please post more!
It is not a mystery why minorities in general and blacks specifically were discriminated against. The religion was invented by 19th century white people. That wasn't "discrimination", that was "normal".
-
- Posts: 2466
- Joined: December 8th, 2016, 7:08 am
- Favorite Philosopher: Socrates
Re: Why are people so against the Mormons?
1. As people have already pointed out they personally find the religious claims made to be unbelievable. This is a common complaint of everyone who isn't in whatever religion is being discussed. Personally I find the religious claims of LDS to be identical to Christianity or any religion. So it's in no way unique or particularly objectionable. Secularism basically deals with the problem, from both sides, and hopefully allows us all to live together in relative harmony.
2. To my mind the real problems with LDS, or any religion, are not so much the beliefs but the behaviours. When religion turns into a cult you have a real and genuine problem. Now I only know LDS through what I have read online and through some podcasts who have interviewed people who have left LDS. Those people certainly described cults. Now you can maybe say ok there are some LDS cults, in the same way there are some Christian cults, but you could argue it's the minority and not the majority. Personally I don't have any facts and figures to hand tp be sure one way or the other.
Lark Truth I assume you are in the LDS church? Can I ask you a question? If you today decided that you no longer believed in the teachings of the church and you wanted to leave. How would your friends/family and fellow church members react?
2024 Philosophy Books of the Month
2023 Philosophy Books of the Month
Mark Victor Hansen, Relentless: Wisdom Behind the Incomparable Chicken Soup for the Soul
by Mitzi Perdue
February 2023
Rediscovering the Wisdom of Human Nature: How Civilization Destroys Happiness
by Chet Shupe
March 2023