My mind being limited, does not mean that my mind has access to 0 semantics or truths. The limits of my mind are shown when I don't know if there as beings with a 10th sense or not. Or when I don't fully know what's on Mars. These are unknowns. They are not known absurdities. I know that a triangle is a three-sided shape. God Knows this too. God does not Know a four-sided triangle because such a thing is a known absurdity. I know it. God Knows it. God Knows what's fully on Mars, or whether beings with a 10th sense exist or not. I don't.Count Lucanor wrote: ↑March 5th, 2021, 10:31 pm If your mind is limited and the omniscient, omnipotent, omnipresent god's mind is not, then you cannot know whether something that appears absurd to your mind, is not absurd in this god's mind. You agree that your knowledge is limited, so you cannot act as if you really knew all.
You did not word it this way. I can better address it this way. In your own words, "if there's a knowledge in the present (A) about a knowledge to be had in the future (B)", then it follows that B is contingent on (A). We agree on this. But you have not commented on the following:I already answered and gave an argument about that. I explained that there's a knowledge in the present (A) about a knowledge to be had in the future (B), remember?
Provided that x's choice is absolutely not contingent on anything else (so it is not contingent on (A)), when is x's choice knowledge to be had? After it is made, or before it is made?
We are all contingent on God. God Is Self-Sufficient. Only God is Truly Free. We're all free within the meaningful limits that God Has Determined for us. No meaningful limits were decided for God. God/Existence just Is Perfect, Infinite etc. Always has been, always will be.
There are thing that are unknown to me. I don't know if a 10th sense is a potentiality of Existence/God, or an absurdity (something that can't exist). God Knows whether's it's an absurdity or not. I don't. I know a four-sided triangle is an absurdity. I know that God Knows this. God Knows that I know that God Knows this.You're saying you know exactly what is absurd in the infinite mind of the omniscient, omnipotent deity, but you said yourself you couldn't know.
No. Omnipotence = being able to do all that is doable. It does not mean being able to be better than perfect (God), or being able to create a four sided triangle. Such suggestions are meaningless. We cannot meaningfully describe them as being doable things, just as we cannot meaningfully describe a square as being three-sided or triangular. Meaningless things are irrelevant to Omnipotence. They are irrelevant to Existence/God.You're even claiming that there are things impossible for this deity to do, so you're actually denying its omnipotence, too. For omnipotence to be possible, anything deemed absurd by a non-omnipotent, non-omniscient being, can only be absurd because the omnipotent being decided that it were absurd for those beings.