Imagine
-
- Posts: 658
- Joined: September 10th, 2017, 11:57 am
Re: Imagine
- Sy Borg
- Site Admin
- Posts: 15154
- Joined: December 16th, 2013, 9:05 pm
Re: Imagine
True! Consider how quickly the neocon movement swept through. I personally think that one individual, Rupert Murdoch, was most instrumental in bringing this about, although if he did not exist the fossil fuel industry probably would have had to invent him.
Imagine Trump's traction today without Fox - he is the primary lifeline. Murdoch controls over 60% of print media in Australia, and it's no coincidence that "left wing" (actually slightly right wing) parties tend to rarely find themselves in power, and that their time in power is fraught with regular full frontal assaults by that 60%. Then the conservative TV and radio hosts use the genuinely fake news of Fox as the basis for their own deeply biased accounts.
The trouble has always been that one side wants to fight according to Marquess of Queensbury rules while the other is a street fighter who will "do whatever it takes". If Obama committed just one of Trump's hundreds of outrageous lies or denial of accountability he would have been impeached by now, and probably in prison. The vultures of Murdoch and his friends swarm, waiting for a chance to take out centrist politicians (especially women) while giving endless passes and smarmy rationalisations to cover for their own side's indiscretions.
Yes, out of ugliness can come goodness, and not just at the scale of dinosaurs. Consider the flourishing of culture and knowledge after the Black Death or how Germany and Japan rebuilt after their humiliating descent into paranoia and madness in the 30s and 40s. It seems that sometimes we have too many people and there is a correction. As Attenborough has repeatedly noted, if humans don't control their population then nature will. In this instance, nature may well be extended to include AI.
-
- Posts: 658
- Joined: September 10th, 2017, 11:57 am
Re: Imagine
In one way or another humanity has evolved from a herd culture to a few variations of a slave culture where a few dominant, mostly males, have domesticated the great mass of the species to benefit them and keep them under control so that the bulk of the wealth is retained by, what we now call, the elites. These elites have evolved various lies or scams to control the great mass of their culture and profess to be wiser and stronger or somehow connected to an imaginary supernatural powerful being and the mass of humanity is convinced from early childhood to swallow this nonsense and accept the role of domesticated cattle to the point where they even willingly die for these corrupt criminals in some weird joy of fulfilling a crazy destiny. In an almost humorous way many of these idiotic elites even come to believe these outright fantasies themselves and a very few who understand the scam and nevertheless are bright enough to fall in with the whole business because it permits a life of luxury and freedom. If any of the general population understands this scam and tries to let his or her fellows in on the tricks being played to control them the elites either corrupt him or her to join them or quickly dispose of whoever might attack the system as being lazy or criminal. These days, the disposal is the business of the police or the CIA or other government agencies in order to preserve the system.
Chomsky makes it clear in his lectures that the general mass of the public can always get rid of their masters by simply refusing to comply with the restrictions that keep them more or less controlled but the quick expansion of tight surveillance through the internet and other surveillance means is now closing in so completely that the elite domination of society makes it almost impossible to change the system into something more decent and rational.
If the controllers of society really cared for the general population and saw to it they were fed and housed and properly educated and cared for medically the system might function sensibly but this rarely happens. The elite has come to believe their stupidities and disdain for average humanity elevates them into some sort of genetic superiority and they always mistreat their domesticated human cattle eventually so badly that the population revolts and the whole mess starts all over again. Or, as in the past, those in control so mistreats the environment that supports them so that the civilization collapses entirely.This is what is happening today but the major difference today is that not one small sector of the Earth is involved, but the entire planet is being so thoroughly destroyed so that there is nowhere that will survive to permit the long redevelopment to take place necessary for a recovery. Beyond that, there is not the slightest indication that any intelligence remains within the powerful to grasp the total catastrophe rapidly approaching so their destructions of the planet is, if anything, speeding up to enhance the total obliteration. If mankind has reached the apex of anything, it is the production of an abysmally idiotic elite that has no understanding of that final suicide of their species and almost all other species on the planet.
- Sy Borg
- Site Admin
- Posts: 15154
- Joined: December 16th, 2013, 9:05 pm
Re: Imagine
Don't talk rubbish, Jan. It's unbecoming for one as bright as you.
At the moment, certainly. However, the rate of change at present is rapid. I think that Musk and co anticipate that once AI reaches the point where it can build better AI than humans can, the rate of technological progress will be increase, possibly exponentially so.Jan Sand wrote:Musk and even Hawking seem to believe that transferring a seed of humanity to Mars is worthwhile to maintain life in this solar system but that strikes me as super optimistic nonsense as humanity has not reached the stage of rationality to make a success of that. We simply do not have the supporting infrastructure to carry it off although it might be managed if the primitive vicious drives that seem basic in humanity can somehow be suppressed. At the moment, that appears very unlikely.
Whatever survives off-world will not be human as we know it. There will be a significant AI component - how much, who can say? Maybe AI is the next evolutionary step? Maybe AI will wake up, or maybe it will just be a conduit for the spread of Earth's life? Or maybe it will transform into Paperclip Maximisers due to a programming error in the core code of the learning module and they turn the entire Earh's surface into paperclips? Or maybe an asteroid or supervolcano will decimate us tomorrow?
It seems so, more or less. As I said earlier, good things can come from apparent ill.Jan Sand wrote:In one way or another humanity has evolved from a herd culture to a few variations of a slave culture where a few dominant, mostly males, have domesticated the great mass of the species to benefit them and keep them under control so that the bulk of the wealth is retained by, what we now call, the elites. These elites have evolved various lies or scams to control the great mass of their culture and profess to be wiser and stronger or somehow connected to an imaginary supernatural powerful being and the mass of humanity is convinced from early childhood to swallow this nonsense and accept the role of domesticated cattle to the point where they even willingly die for these corrupt criminals in some weird joy of fulfilling a crazy destiny. In an almost humorous way many of these idiotic elites even come to believe these outright fantasies themselves and a very few who understand the scam and nevertheless are bright enough to fall in with the whole business because it permits a life of luxury and freedom. If any of the general population understands this scam and tries to let his or her fellows in on the tricks being played to control them the elites either corrupt him or her to join them or quickly dispose of whoever might attack the system as being lazy or criminal. These days, the disposal is the business of the police or the CIA or other government agencies in order to preserve the system.
Trump followers would agree with you. They think that they are "draining the swamp" by installing its largest alligator. It is remarkable what people can be prompted to believe with the right propaganda and conditioning.Jan Sand wrote:Chomsky makes it clear in his lectures that the general mass of the public can always get rid of their masters by simply refusing to comply with the restrictions that keep them more or less controlled
I think that if people were race horses then the form is there - most of the wealthy never have much cared. They often do care somewhat but I find people generally don't much care about others because they are so busy keeping their own lives together. Rather, both rich and poor people tend to care most about themselves and their own, although spheres of concern obviously vary from person to person, and that includes in elite circles.Jan Sand wrote:If the controllers of society really cared for the general population and saw to it they were fed and housed and properly educated and cared for medically the system might function sensibly but this rarely happens.
Plenty do care but they don't have much influence because such ethical people tend to "play by Marquess of Queensbury" rules whereas the self-entitled ruthless types shamelessly go straight for the jugular and gonads and then scream loudly via their loaded news outlets should there be any retaliation. It's a stitch-up - Orwell and Huxley were visionaries, as was Sagan.
Yet again. A biosphere that does not change becomes stagnant, and then change will be inevitable.Jan Sand wrote:This is what is happening today but the major difference today is that not one small sector of the Earth is involved, but the entire planet is being so thoroughly destroyed so that there is nowhere that will survive to permit the long redevelopment to take place necessary for a recovery.
There is not one serious observer who predicts total obliteration. What they expect are many disasters and problems for most people and animals.Jan Sand wrote:Beyond that, there is not the slightest indication that any intelligence remains within the powerful to grasp the total catastrophe rapidly approaching so their destructions of the planet is, if anything, speeding up to enhance the total obliteration.
-
- Posts: 658
- Joined: September 10th, 2017, 11:57 am
Re: Imagine
Incidentally, my opinion of myself is not false modesty. I have tested myself in many directions and I speak out of considered experience. Chomsky is a couple of years younger than me and experienced the same eras and used that raw material to far better consequence so I have a comparison to judge myself and I in no way measure up even microscopically.
- Sy Borg
- Site Admin
- Posts: 15154
- Joined: December 16th, 2013, 9:05 pm
Re: Imagine
Jan, most of us are probably not going to measure up intellectually with Chomsky or other geniuses in public life :)
That video is really long and I won't get to it today. Any help there appreciated.
-
- Posts: 658
- Joined: September 10th, 2017, 11:57 am
Re: Imagine
- Felix
- Posts: 3117
- Joined: February 9th, 2009, 5:45 am
Re: Imagine
I hadn't heard that one, very funny. Must be why I rarely see time fly - I am not an archer.
Groucho also said: "Outside of a dog, a book is your best friend - and inside of a dog, its too dark to read."
"Creative people frequently take to alcohol or drugs or God."
Far less frequently than non-creative people.
Re: your quip about dinosaur technology and Greta's reply, "Well then where is it?"
Rumor is it was not a hardware based technology but a psychic one. They may still be among us, you sometimes hear someone say, "I couldn't help myself, my lizard brain took over" (a variation of "the devil made me do it"). Well, it may not have been their lizard brain.
There is a Ray Bradbury story about human travelers to Mars, who possessed nuclear weapons, being overcome by the Martians mind control technology - don't know if the Martians had a reptilian appearance, maybe so and that's where they went to evade the Earth's deadly meteor shower which then killed all their dumb cousins.
-
- Posts: 658
- Joined: September 10th, 2017, 11:57 am
Re: Imagine
- Sy Borg
- Site Admin
- Posts: 15154
- Joined: December 16th, 2013, 9:05 pm
Re: Imagine
Interesting that nasty aliens are depicted as being human-sized but with either microbial, insectoid or reptilian qualities. (Or humanoid, of course). We fear the unreason of simple beasts that cannot comprehend mercy or ethics and we fear that element within ourselves. We also fear the possibility of regression back to those base mentalities, exemplified by The Lord of the Flies and more religions than you can poke a stick at.
What I wonder about is what Trump supporters will do if he loses or is removed for corruption. They had a lot to say about the bad behaviour of the left after Trump won - claiming this as evidence that the left were more violent and uncivilised than the right (never mind the KKK). I wonder if they will show discipline when their side goes down on democracy's see-saw?
This is what happens when democracy stops being a true democracy. In nations where elections are held purely for appearance's sake to legitimise an illegitimate autocrat, post-election violence is common. The unfairness deepens societal divisions by fostering resentment. In time, as authoritarians strengthen their grip on power it seems that a national version of the Stockholm syndrome takes place. In effect, as citizens are beaten down and the (unethical) efficiencies of authoritarianism provide its usual short-term gains, there will increasingly effectively be a significant rump in the population of willing, unquestioning, browbeaten, quasi-deifying Winston Smiths. A machine needs its components to operate as per spec.
-
- Posts: 658
- Joined: September 10th, 2017, 11:57 am
Re: Imagine
https://www.counterpunch.org/2018/05/07 ... scription/
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5BXtgq0Nhsc
This will lift the propaganda tarpaulins just a small bit to hopefully dispel the current nonsense of democracy as it exists in the world. As Gandhi once remarked when asked his opinion of human civilization "It's a good idea".
-
- Posts: 658
- Joined: September 10th, 2017, 11:57 am
Re: Imagine
I have yet to see any SF story wherein an alien AI enters our internet system to disrupt our susceptible systems. Since they can easily roam the universe at light velocity this might be a actual possibility..
- Sy Borg
- Site Admin
- Posts: 15154
- Joined: December 16th, 2013, 9:05 pm
Re: Imagine
Yes, a huge issue. On the plus side, I do not see insectoid, reptilian or amoeba-like beings as like to foster the nous and cooperation to build a grass hut let alone a space program. Any technologically advanced species will either be effectively eusocial, with specialised functions, or a hive mind. Given the increasing pervasiveness of the digital world, our societal structures may eventually develop into a hive mind as the next step.
Whatever they are, they will have stronger curiosity than a desire to eat everything living and juicy that they encounter. Death by dissection by hypothetical aliens rather than predation would seem more plausible, although any species capable of interstellar travel will also be capable of non-destructive analysis of specimens and perhaps such powerful telescopy that they can already watch the dinosaurs in action on Earth!
Most of the animals alive now are amongst the most instinctively fearful of humans - hence their current existence. Daily benign interaction is needed over a period to earn their trust - which doesn't mean that you can necessarily trust them :) Often things that we take for granted can make a big difference to small animals. I reduced the aggression of the ant nest next to my house by simply being careful not to step on them on the front stairs and leaving tidbits in their trail (reduces need to span out into my house). I realised that if there is not periodic carnage meted out on the nest then the animals are less agitated. A community of any species, including humans, would not respond wildly differently.Jan Sand wrote:My own attempt at conversation with a praying mantis proved totally futile even though she watched me closely and turned her head as I approached.
I have watched people walking on a footpath with a magpie feeding just up ahead of them. They simply stroll through the bird's space as if it didn't matter, forcing it to flee. Then they wonder why these intelligent birds, which can recognise and remember human individuals for years, swoop them. I show the birds respect, giving them space, and I coo at them (acknowledgement - intelligent animals like that) and occasionally feed them. So they don't swoop at me.
There must be countless other instances where obliviousness creates tensions with local animals that could easily be avoided.
-
- Posts: 658
- Joined: September 10th, 2017, 11:57 am
Re: Imagine
-
- Posts: 28
- Joined: March 2nd, 2024, 3:05 am
Re: Imagine
But now I see some point to it. Like religion can be very strict and repressive and that is why there are so many wars over it.
And a world with no possessions, I think he was trying to say that people get too caught up in materialism rather than just loving and being peaceful souls.
I think you know he looked like he had a face that hated humans and sometimes it is easy to see why when humans can be so greedy, self centred and barbaric.
I think he really was a sort of peacekeeper where he believed in free love that people could be who they were and live in freedom where they were not oppressed.
He was a hippy and a bohemian and I think he would have struggled to fit in a world where people could not be themselves and were so violent.
2024 Philosophy Books of the Month
2023 Philosophy Books of the Month
Mark Victor Hansen, Relentless: Wisdom Behind the Incomparable Chicken Soup for the Soul
by Mitzi Perdue
February 2023
Rediscovering the Wisdom of Human Nature: How Civilization Destroys Happiness
by Chet Shupe
March 2023