Why do people kill each other?
-
- Posts: 307
- Joined: August 31st, 2012, 6:21 pm
Why do people kill each other?
So, independent of religion, by default. Why do humans in general kill each other?
I am not talking about self defence, I'm talking about the instigator who decides taking another person's life is worth it.
Why does one decide to kill another person, how does it happen in the mind? What is the thought process that triggers a green light response when murder comes up in the brain? Why does anyone have a murder thought at all?
Is it a mental problem, or inability of certain human beings to evolve to the point of possessing common sense or just the way it is and couldn't be any other way?
- Eckhart Aurelius Hughes
- The admin formerly known as Scott
- Posts: 5765
- Joined: January 20th, 2007, 6:24 pm
- Favorite Philosopher: Eckhart Aurelius Hughes
- Contact:
Re: Why do people kill each other?
Any given taxonomy can categorize groups of killers with similar reasons into groups, but then there would still be multiple groups. Also, needless to say, there's a degree of arbitrariness in any taxonomy. And it's important to note that similar doesn't mean same.
"The mind is a wonderful servant but a terrible master."
I believe spiritual freedom (a.k.a. self-discipline) manifests as bravery, confidence, grace, honesty, love, and inner peace.
-
- Posts: 307
- Joined: August 31st, 2012, 6:21 pm
Re: Why do people kill each other?
It would be fascinating to know how the thought process of a killer becomes practically manifest.
- LuckyR
- Moderator
- Posts: 7932
- Joined: January 18th, 2015, 1:16 am
Re: Why do people kill each other?
Secondly and rarely, is the crime of passion where there is little to no consideration of the moral standard due to undue emotional upheaval. IMO this is extremely rare and many if not most such cases are legal strategies rather than true incidents.
Lastly and more what the OP is driving at is folks who make a decision to commit murder based on a moral calculation where perhaps in this one case given the circumstances it is ok to commit murder, this of course would be the definition of murder in the first degree.
-
- Posts: 1719
- Joined: February 23rd, 2012, 3:06 am
Re: Why do people kill each other?
-
- Posts: 3119
- Joined: November 26th, 2011, 8:10 pm
- Favorite Philosopher: Terry Pratchett
Re: Why do people kill each other?
Just quoting George Carlin, who, sadly, can't be with us today.
-
- Posts: 307
- Joined: August 31st, 2012, 6:21 pm
Re: Why do people kill each other?
So, it would be easier to ascert that murders are either sociopaths or people instinctively allowing their undilluted natural brain function to have its way. I think it's also sociopathic or retardation to refuse to use the brain to do what it can, especially if it negatively affects somebody else. Of course negative and positive would mean something different to the person, which further proves that they're sociopaths, since the person is living among people who use their brain for moral judgement for the benefit of all humanity.LuckyR wrote: ↑March 20th, 2019, 6:13 pm There are three main ways that individuals reconcile murder with their moral standard: firstly and most importantly sociopaths have no moral standard, so to them murder is just another tool in the toolbox to solve problems. At 2% of the population that is 150 million potential murderers worldwide.
Secondly and rarely, is the crime of passion where there is little to no consideration of the moral standard due to undue emotional upheaval. IMO this is extremely rare and many if not most such cases are legal strategies rather than true incidents.
Lastly and more what the OP is driving at is folks who make a decision to commit murder based on a moral calculation where perhaps in this one case given the circumstances it is ok to commit murder, this of course would be the definition of murder in the first degree.
Which raises another question.
Should murderers be treated or penalized?
-
- Posts: 3119
- Joined: November 26th, 2011, 8:10 pm
- Favorite Philosopher: Terry Pratchett
Re: Why do people kill each other?
That depends on how you define murder. Do you include soldiers killing soldiers or soldiers killing civilians? Do you include executioners? Doctors who perform euthanasia? Only people who kill people of their own nationality/race/class or all kinds of other people, or just people who can't defend themselves, or all species that can't fight back, or ... what?
"Murder" is a legal term to separate one class of killing from all the other kinds of killing. The definition is neither universal nor constant.
What I'm saying is: in the natural course of things, animals kill other animals. Humans and human activities are nothing more esoteric than a continuation of animal behaviour in more complex directions. Because we do complicate things, we sort killing into different categories.
-
- Posts: 307
- Joined: August 31st, 2012, 6:21 pm
Re: Why do people kill each other?
At the beginning of the post I did exclude self defense, which is kind of the category that war falls in. Anyways, cut long story short, I'm talking about murder with no rational reasonable basis.Alias wrote: ↑March 27th, 2019, 12:11 pmThat depends on how you define murder. Do you include soldiers killing soldiers or soldiers killing civilians? Do you include executioners? Doctors who perform euthanasia? Only people who kill people of their own nationality/race/class or all kinds of other people, or just people who can't defend themselves, or all species that can't fight back, or ... what?
"Murder" is a legal term to separate one class of killing from all the other kinds of killing. The definition is neither universal nor constant.
Even revenge isn't a sensible reason to murder someone imo
You see animals kill, because their life and/or survival depends on it. Coupled with the fact that they can't reason. Those are 2 serious reasons that keep us far apart. I believe we are reasonable for a reason. You and I would be perfectly fine if we minded our business and do the needful, which may never involve anything remotely close to one killing the otherAlias wrote: ↑March 27th, 2019, 12:11 pm What I'm saying is: in the natural course of things, animals kill other animals. Humans and human activities are nothing more esoteric than a continuation of animal behaviour in more complex directions. Because we do complicate things, we sort killing into different categories.
-
- Posts: 3119
- Joined: November 26th, 2011, 8:10 pm
- Favorite Philosopher: Terry Pratchett
Re: Why do people kill each other?
Only for a nation under unprovoked attack.
Nobody kills anybody without a reason. Whether their reason seems rational to you is very much beside the point.Anyways, cut long story short, I'm talking about murder with no rational reasonable basis.
I don't see how those things are coupled. Killing to survive seems eminently reasonable to me. However, the more intelligent animals do sometimes kill for fun, or in anger, just as humans do. And humans still kill - a lot! - for food, which seems to them reasonable, even though it's no longer necessary.You see animals kill, because their life and/or survival depends on it. Coupled with the fact that they can't reason.
To keep whom far apart? Humans from animals?Those are 2 serious reasons that keep us far apart.
What would that reason be? And what's your reason for believing it?I believe we are reasonable for a reason.
Mostly it doesn't. Mostly, people can manage enough organization within their community, and enough indifference to non-members of their community, to keep neighbours and strangers from killing one another personally.You and I would be perfectly fine if we minded our business and do the needful, which may never involve anything remotely close to one killing the other
But there has never been a single week in recorded history that people were not killed in some kind of conflict, formal or informal, or sacrifice, or punishment, or just because someone powerful feared them.
Humans are very far from being reasonable animals.
-
- Posts: 307
- Joined: August 31st, 2012, 6:21 pm
Re: Why do people kill each other?
How is it beside the point? I'm being affected by it too so why shouldn't my view on it be seen as a valid point?
Maybe, I'm not explaining myself well enough.Alias wrote: ↑March 27th, 2019, 3:32 pm I don't see how those things are coupled. Killing to survive seems eminently reasonable to me. However, the more intelligent animals do sometimes kill for fun, or in anger, just as humans do. And humans still kill - a lot! - for food, which seems to them reasonable, even though it's no longer necessary.
One could kill oneself, for whatever reason, that's their problem. But, when it has to affect someone else then that person do not have the right to judge their rationality at the detriment someone else. That act ceases to be reasonable once one starts assuming that their view in life should be standard. While if they don't and just want to enforce it by force then, thus my initial question.
To whom much is given, much is tested. Humans have higher intelligence than animals to reason is needed to create order.
Mostly it doesn't. Mostly, people can manage enough organization within their community, and enough indifference to non-members of their community, to keep neighbours and strangers from killing one another personally.You and I would be perfectly fine if we minded our business and do the needful, which may never involve anything remotely close to one killing the other
But there has never been a single week in recorded history that people were not killed in some kind of conflict, formal or informal, or sacrifice, or punishment, or just because someone powerful feared them.
Humans are very far from being reasonable animals.
[/quote]
No humans are not, but compared to animals humans are very reasonable.
Back to the topic
I'm curious. Do you think murder is just a normal way of life that should just be embraced and move on? Like when someone dies we'd be like "oh well, tough luck... Moving on. Who's next on the menu?"
- Plaffelvohfen
- New Trial Member
- Posts: 14
- Joined: March 5th, 2019, 1:40 am
Re: Why do people kill each other?
Our violence operates far outside the bounds of any other species. Human beings kill anything. Slaughter is a defining behavior of our species. We kill all other creatures, and we kill our own. Read today’s paper. Read yesterday’s, or read tomorrow’s. The enormous industry of print and broadcast journalism serves predominantly to document our killing. Violence exists in the animal world, of course, but on a far different scale. Carnivores kill for food; we kill our family members, our children, our parents, our spouses, our brothers and sisters, our cousins and in-laws. We kill strangers. We kill people who are different from us, in appearance, beliefs, race, and social status. We kill ourselves in suicide. We kill for advantage and for revenge, we kill for entertainment: the Roman Coliseum, drive-by shootings, bullfights, hunting and fishing, animal roadkill in an instantaneous reflex for sport. We kill friends, rivals, coworkers, and classmates. Children kill children, in school and on the playground. Grandparents, parents, fathers, mothers--all kill and all of them are the targets of killing…
The reasons can be traced back to our primate ancestors, which are exceptionally violent creatures, killing each other at a rate of 2.3% like we do. These data indicate that the incessant repetition throughout recorded history and in prehistoric times of murder and war among all cultures of human beings has its roots in our evolutionary stalk. In part, the reasons for this rampant self-killing appear to relate to our big brains and the conscious awareness and conniving that big brainpower makes possible, but primarily because of two other key aspects of Homo sapiens and other primates: fierce territoriality and living in social groups. Across all mammalian species, conspecific deadly violence is highly correlated with these two factors. A double hit of both factors compounds the violence. Whales and bats are highly social, but not territorial, for example, and they have very low rates of killing their own kind. Human beings are highly social but extremely territorial--“Trespassers will be shot!” “He cut into my lane!”
When researchers examined how different types of social groups of humans affect the rate of killing, they found that lethal violence was common in present-day societies organized into bands or tribes, and severe violence is frequent in chiefdoms because of territorial disputes, population and resource pressures, and competition for political reasons, but violence decreased in state-run societies. Presumably, the authors conclude, this is because socio-political organizations of populations in state-run societies that are designed to suppress violence and respond to it, act to inhibit the innate, genetically-predisposed propensity of people to kill each other. Consider, for example, if there were no police to call, what would you have to do?
We are evolutionarily and genetically predisposed to snap in deadly violence, but in comparison to other animals, biology has indeed endowed our species with extraordinary “sapiens.” The problem is that the neural circuits of violence that cause us to explode in rage and violence are deep in the brain beneath the cerebral cortex where consciousness arises. The frontal lobes of the brain can squelch these circuits of rage that we share with other violent mammals, but this “top-down” conscious control of our violent impulses is slower to act than the circuits of explosive violence deep in our brain. Understanding this neurocircuitry is vital. Territoriality and social interactions are the “E” for environment, and “T” for tribe, triggers of sudden aggression in the mnemonic “LIFEMORTS,” which is a convenient way to learn to recognize the 9 triggers of rage. Each of these triggers of rage activates different neural circuits in the brain’s threat-detection mechanism. Learning about these biologically and genetically embedded triggers of violence can enable us to engage the part of the human brain that distinguishes it from all other mammalian brains--the forebrain.
-
- Posts: 3119
- Joined: November 26th, 2011, 8:10 pm
- Favorite Philosopher: Terry Pratchett
Re: Why do people kill each other?
Because your opinion doesn't influence the killer.
Nor does it have any appreciable effect on human behaviour in general.
Laws already exist: your influence extends precisely to the limit of your political power.
It also makes no difference to human behaviour, or law, what you think other people have a right to think.Maybe, I'm not explaining myself well enough.
One could kill oneself, for whatever reason, that's their problem. But, when it has to affect someone else then that person do not have the right to judge their rationality at the detriment someone else.
I'm not sure what that means.That act ceases to be reasonable once one starts assuming that their view in life should be standard. While if they don't and just want to enforce it by force then, thus my initial question.
That's your reason for believing that it should be true. All right, but it's not substantiated by what actually happens in the world.[There is a reason for reason -- What would that reason be? And what's your reason for believing it?]
To whom much is given, much is tested. Humans have higher intelligence than animals to reason is needed to create order.
You probably have a reason for believing that, too. All right.
No humans are not, but compared to animals humans are very reasonable.
Your phraseology makes this difficult to answer, but I'll try.I'm curious. Do you think murder is just a normal way of life that should just be embraced and move on?
Yes, killing is very much a normal human activity.
'Murder', as I've mentioned above, is a legal classification of unauthorized killing, and that classification changes from time to time and varies from culture to culture. However, in all civilized cultures, illegal killing of one citizen by another does happen, though not with equal frequency, so I'm willing to posit that it's also normal.
There is a difference between recognizing reality and embracing it. The latter has not been an issue hitherto. As for moving on, the alternative is total paralysis.
That depend on our relationship to the dead person. The last sentence is merely frivolous.Like when someone dies we'd be like "oh well, tough luck... Moving on. Who's next on the menu?"
-
- Posts: 307
- Joined: August 31st, 2012, 6:21 pm
Re: Why do people kill each other?
No offence to people who think life is a gift but it's such a cruel and unworthy experience.
-
- Posts: 307
- Joined: August 31st, 2012, 6:21 pm
Re: Why do people kill each other?
2023/2024 Philosophy Books of the Month
Mark Victor Hansen, Relentless: Wisdom Behind the Incomparable Chicken Soup for the Soul
by Mitzi Perdue
February 2023
Rediscovering the Wisdom of Human Nature: How Civilization Destroys Happiness
by Chet Shupe
March 2023